Our market systems are not perfect; capitalism squashes the little guy, communism is ripe with corruption. But as we embrace the 21st century we need to try iterations and hybrids to approach a fair and free society. I may be biased but I believe the NZ/European blend of public good and free market are getting pretty close.
In artificial intelligence design you have to be careful to avoid a local minima; a solution that is the best for the given values, but not the best overall. You do this by shaking up the network once in a while, give it something random to consider, jagged and unexpected.
Civilisation has reached a local minima by weighing up only free market and public good, where money is the measure. We need a jolt of new alternative ideas for society. One such project is a resource based global economy described in the documentary “Zeitgeist Moving Forward”, if you have a free hour you can watch it here. Or the budding social entrepreneurship movement.
But regarding communism; this is an insightful extract from “Iconoclast” by Gregory Burns:
…[Imagine] if two animals got together and somehow agreed to share food that they found. As long as they trust each other, these cooperating creatures stand to do substantially better in the race for survival. In fact, evolution pretty much guarantees that such cooperative relationships will be discovered by animals because they are superior to completely self-interested strategies of survival. But there is a wrinkle in this story. Imagine an entire colony of these friendly creatures, which willingly cooperate with each other, sharing food and shelter. Such a love-fest creates the opportunity for more sinister operatives to take advantage of their trusting counterparts. In a culture of complete and absolute trust, evolution begins to favour creatures that can deceive other members of the species. The final balance between cooperation and deception is called an Evolutionary Stable Strategy. It means that in any society there will always be a mix of cooperation and deception. It is only the possibility of deception that confers value to cooperation.
That resonated with my plans for Stocktrack. The stock market assumes crowds working towards their own self-interest, where Stocktrack plans to unite people online to form discrete teams and share or even donate the profits. Hopefully we’ll shake up the paradigm.
What I find interesting about the evolutionary stable strategy is that it not only dismisses pure communism, but also pure capitalism. We can’t abide people pushing the free market ideal when evolution indicates that it doesn’t work in the long run. What do you think is the best way forward in 2012?


Lessons, musings and notes on my journey to save the world.